Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Pizza Box Nachos - Small
Ale Haus Reuben - Regular
Veggie Calzone - Calzone
Mushroom Calzone - Calzone
About
Angie's New York Style Pizzeria
Welcome to Angie's New York Style Pizzeria, a hidden gem nestled in Mentor, Ohio. Located at 7875 Munson Rd, this pizzeria captures the essence of true New York-style pizza, offering a hand-crafted experience that distinguishes it from the ordinary. With a commitment to quality, Angie's prides itself on its handmade, never-frozen pizza crusts, embracing authenticity with each slice.
As you step in, the aroma of freshly baked dough and quality ingredients envelops you. The menu showcases a delightful array of options, from their Two Topping New York Style Cheese Pizza, available in a 12" small or a 16" large, to unique specialties that promise to tantalize your taste buds. The cheesy allure of their Four Cheese Calzone ($14.30) or the savory goodness of the Loaded French Fry Stromboli ($18.20) will leave you craving more. Each dish is a testament to the pizzeria's dedication to freshness and flavor.
But it’s not just the food that sets Angie's apart; the warm hospitality of the staff enhances the overall dining experience. Customers have praised their friendliness, highlighting moments of kindness that have made their visits memorable. One guest fondly recalls how the team accommodated a late order on Christmas Eve, showcasing their commitment to customer satisfaction.
The rave reviews keep pouring in. Iuliia Marshall describes Angie's as her favorite spot for white pizza, while Rachel Hannon appreciates the beautifully baked crust of her pizza, a true hallmark of a quality New York-style pizzeria. Mark Ulis echoes these sentiments, noting the sensational brick-oven pizza and delectable homemade cheesecake that leave a lasting impression.
For a truly satisfying meal, dive into the famous Pepperoni Rolls ($13.00) or the filling Grilled Cheese Sandwich ($11.70), both beloved by regulars. Many have shared how they always look forward to their weekly visits, making Angie's not just a place to eat, but a cherished part of their routine.
In summary, Angie's New York Style Pizzeria is not just about food; it's about passion, family, and a dedication to serving the community with excellence. If you're in Mentor, don’t miss the chance to visit. Your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ One of our most fav pizzas in the area! Love East of Clevelander white pizza. We feel that it is the best white pizza in the area. Staff is always very friendly. During Christmas Eve last year, they were so sweet to let us order 10 min before closing. Our family loves this place! ”
“ Wow! This place rocks! This pizza is gorgeous! Lovely undercarriage as well, nicely browned and dusty the way I expect from a new York stone oven. Really quality ingredients. Really well done guys. Been eating here since about 2006? Still fantastic every time. ”
“ First time I ordered from here. The owner was so nice, and patient. She answered every question without an attitude. The pizza was sensational (I love brick/stone ovens. The homemade cheesecake was delicious and a very big piece. The handmade mozzarella sticks were also excellent. You can always taste the difference between frozen and hand made fresh. That is just the top of the iceberg of their menu. From what I was told pretty much if not all is homemade. I will be ordering from this place again. ”
“ I’ve been going to Angie’s with my husband for over a year now. We always go on Wednesdays and get an order of the pepperoni rolls, and the loaded fries. Both are melt in your mouth amazing and full of flavor. The pepperoni rolls have a melted butter and seasoning topping on them, and the breading is always cooked to perfection. We have to cut our rolls into 4 pieces because I can never finish all of mine, they are really a great size, and they have a deal on Wednesday for their pepperoni rolls. The fries are super good as well, topped with cheese, bacon and jalapeno’s and comes with sour cream. I absolutely love Angie’s, and I’ll go here for many many years to come. ”
“ I ordered Angie’s pizza for the first time and it it’s sooooo good!! Everything tastes exceptional! Definitely recommend! ”
“ Ordered from here, first time tonight with Uber eats. Got the lasagna and it was very good! Huge portion too. Would definitely get again. ”
“ Love Angie’s! A lot of love goes into not only their pizza, but their other menu items as well. Their pizza dough is hand made and tossed and ingredients are fresh! ”
“ Wow those pepperoni rolls I just ordered BOGO are amazing for 10 !!! Met Christina and she’s got great vibes!!! Excellent service!! Ready in less then 20 minutes!! Looks beautiful smells great! Thank you to Angie’s!!!! My son loves it! ”